RE: The Tragic Transformation of the West

avatar
(Edited)

You are viewing a single comment's thread:

Excellent detailed post but I feel that while you have examined the detail excellently you have actually missed the bigger picture.

It is not just The West that is collapsing. It is human civilisation as a whole with very limited exceptions.

The collapse in not primarily driven by economic factors, although they certainly play a role, it is driven by collapsing biological/ physiological/epigenetic civilisational values (read BioHistory by Prof Jim Penman) and the related collapse of fertility.
Fiat currency debasement also plays a part but is a symptom more than a cause.

Fertility has collapsed to by far the lowest levels recorded in human history (half and even one third of replacement) across almost the entire globe. This includes the Muslim world (incl Muslims in The West), South America, North and South Asia. The only continent that remains above replacement is third world Africa and even there fertility is falling rapidly. Global fertility is now below replacement for the first time ever.

What faces the world is far worse than any of the examples you have given. The closest parallel is the Bronze Age Collapse, but that only affected the cradle of civilisation, a relatively small area. This is a collapse that encompasses almost the entire world.

The entire economic system that has driven progress & technological advancement for almost 1000 years has been based on population growth. It is impossible to sustain economic growth and technological progress without it.

Young people drive innovation, tech progress and consumer spending. They defend a country. They pay the taxes that support the national infrastructure and the aged. They produce the next generation. Without sufficient numbers of them civilisation collapses.

The engine has failed and the pilots (elites) are using increasingly desperate and counterproductive band aids to maintain the appearance of growth, or at least smooth flight, so consumer and investor confidence does not utterly collapse. This includes massive money printing, mass illegal migration, stoking societal divisions and many of the specific policy errors you have dealt with above.

There is only one country that is a complete exception to this dire picture and I'm more glad every day that I moved there.



0
0
0.000
2 comments
avatar

I thought I was pessimistic. You make some great and very disturbing points.

The rise of feminism, the collapse of Christian values, the destruction of the extended family, obsession with materialism, urbanisation, the shift from perceiving children as assets to expensive liabilities, etc. have played key roles in the falling birth rates in the West.

Some of these reasons apply to wealthier countries in the East such as South Korea, Singapore, and Japan. China's one-child policy has permanently shifted its culture away from having children.

There have been decades of propaganda warning about overpopulation. I think this was one of Bill Gates' favourite topics. I remember being taught in school about exponential population growth, which would eventually lead to global starvation. Even then, birth rates were below replacement rates. It wasn't a concern; it was actually desired.

The falling birth rate in the third-world countries is probably a good thing for now. Places like Somalia still have around 6 births per woman. The Democrats seem very keen on bringing them to America.

0
0
0.000