Can the Left in Latin America Rebuild Itself?

First, we have to distinguish which Left is supposed to return, or what we are prepared to settle for. In this regard, the first question is whether the Left must be anti-capitalist or not, anti-imperialist or not, timid or not; whether it plays by the rules of liberal democracy or not, both in its identity and in the practical expression of that identity.

The so-called “Pink Tide” of the first decade of this century feels like ancient history from today's perspective. In Venezuela, the Rodríguez brothers' Chavismo 3.0 is bowing its head to Washington—quite literally, if we consider the astonishing official celebrations of the American Declaration of Independence, complete with a toast. Evo Morales ended up at loggerheads with another Aymara, Choquehuanca (this split, given that both come from the same Indigenous ethnic group, is more significant than his fruitless feud with Arce). Correa is in exile in Belgium, his first successor betrayed him, and his latest political bet, Luisa González, is behind bars. We will not get into the often murky judicial proceedings that have led to these outcomes, nor into the authoritarian, quasi-dictatorial nature of Daniel Noboa's government. For now, let us look at the practical reality.

Image taken from Jorge Rodríguez's official Telegram channel

Over time, in Uruguay, the late Mujica renounced Marxism and, to a considerable extent, went on to defend the institutions of capitalism. Yamandú Orsi, incidentally, is a long way from being Mujica. We know where Cristina Fernández and the complacent Peronism ended up. It is about as far left as anyone can get while holding court at the Pink House, but it does not represent Argentina's more homegrown Left: the one that urged voters to hold their noses and vote for Sergio Massa rather than Milei, choosing the lesser of two evils. Petro failed to ensure that his political force would remain in the Nariño's House, and his international impact was limited, beyond his posts on X. In Brazil, it remains to be seen whether Lula, particularly if he understands that this really will be his final term, can recover at least half of what Lula 1.0 represented. Even then, he never fully won over or satisfied the interests of the vast majority of his electoral base, including the Landless Workers' Movement and left-wing figures such as Frei Betto.

Mexico is there and not there, but everyone looks toward the United States and fears it, especially in the age of Trump. Cuba's case proves it. In Peru, it proved impossible to prevent the shameful return of a Fujimori to the seat of government in the Pizarro's House. Gabriel Boric betrayed himself, and the result is a Kast whose ship has already begun to take on water. In Panama, Honduras, and Guatemala—in the latter, with Juan José Arévalo's son in the presidency—the Left is failing to get its act together, caught between self-inflicted setback and external obstruction.

The outlook is hardly encouraging. Some sectors of the Left have ended up administering their positions of power with greater concern for preserving them than for transforming the conditions that made their arrival possible. They have confused pragmatism with surrender, alliances with principles, and governability with immobility. This reveals how difficult it has become to turn electoral victories and access to government into lasting transformation.

And, after all, the most important question is this: where are the people grounded in that part of the political spectrum? The people with drive, strength, a desire for change, and the resolve not to give in or go home without seeing their major demands for change met. Are they reduced to the thousand or so people who recently took to the streets in Ecuador to denounce Daniel Noboa? Will the Left struggle to make a forceful return to Paraguay's López Palace after the Ueno Bank affair?

Rebuilding it, then, cannot simply mean waiting for the Right to wear itself out, capitalizing on its mistakes, or finding new faces for the next electoral contests. If it does not want to be subsumed, the Left must step forward and fight for its place; recover its identity and its ability to mobilize, and rebuild from the ground up. Otherwise, it will end up trapped in a managerial Left, held hostage by agendas that are no less conservative simply because they favor electoral alliances and the preservation of the status quo. And perhaps, by then, the question will no longer be whether the Left can return, but whether, when it does, it will still be the Left.

Source for the cover image, generated with GPT technology; source for the one showing Jorge Rodríguez.



0
0
0.000
1 comments
avatar

@limonta's week on scrobble.life 🎵

limonta — this week

This week: 74 music scrobbles · 5 hrs listened · top artists: Anoushka Shankar, Ella Fitzgerald, Grover Washington, Jr..

All-time

limonta — all-time

Full breakdown → https://scrobble.life/u/limonta/stats


Auto-posted by scrobble.life, the open music scrobbler on Hive. Author rewards are burned. Don't want these? Reply STOP or turn them off on your profile.

0
0
0.000