The Challenge of Apportioning Responsibility for Cuba’s Polycrisis

Apportioning causal responsibility for Cuba’s polycrisis between external and internal factors remains a largely unexplored scientific endeavor. Some see the Cuban government as primarily responsible for the country's predicament, while others regard the increasingly aggressive and punitive U.S. policy as the factor that explains almost everything. And some acknowledge shared, balanced responsibility, considering any percentage-based allocation—how much of the overall burden is attributed to each factor—subjective and potentially adjustable in either direction. I count myself among this latter group.
Yet, again, the rigorous scientific work required to address this question, involving the systematic examination of every single factor, external and internal, broken down into its constituent elements, has not been done. Clearly, such an undertaking would itself be shaped by subjectivity and ideological affiliations, since science always develops within a specific context that encourages certain lines of inquiry, constrains others, and influences those engaged in it. The point, however, is that, as a rule, this kind of research should rest on firmer foundations and be better protected against extremism and crude analytical distortions.
I consider external factors the most decisive, either because they are the actual underlying cause of the problems or because they can at least provide a rational explanation for them. They can be facts or working hypotheses, but the mere possibility of advancing them as such casts a heavy shadow: one that either prevents sociopolitical progress or clouds our thinking. Consider Cuba's democratic shortcomings. I start from the premise that liberal democracy is not necessarily a robust model of democracy—I would hardly consider the Biden/Harris versus Donald Trump showdown in the United States a particularly compelling demonstration of democratic choice. Nevertheless, the Cuban alternative has not demonstrated sufficient maturity across a range of areas, including the administration of political dissent and rights that are not "bourgeois" privileges but inalienable individual rights, such as freedom of expression.
Now, it is rational to consider the possibility of an authoritarian inclination within the historical and contemporary political leadership of the process we know as the Cuban Revolution. At the same time, it is entirely plausible to argue that this leadership has necessarily had to resort to restricting a representative range of political rights as a means of defending itself against the blatant and open interference of the United States in Cuba's internal affairs, whose declared objective is regime change and whose actions are consistent with that goal. In other words, if Washington supports media outlets through covert—or, at the very least, less-than-transparent—means, is the decision not to make room for an independent press entirely outside the bounds of rational political reasoning? If the same applies to certain political actors who challenge the legitimacy of the existing political system, is an aversion to dissenting activity altogether unexpected?
None of this legitimizes or condones any documented act of repression or political harassment. Such conduct falls within the realm of the referred inability to manage, in the most coherent and legally sound manner, a real and objective national security problem. Abstracting and disentangling these factors to examine the political dimension of the crisis scientifically is a monumental, almost Herculean task. It may be even more challenging than doing so in the economic sphere, where the impact of individual variables is comparatively easier to isolate.
Source for the cover image, obtained via X.

@limonta's week on scrobble.life 🎵
This week: 52 music scrobbles · 5 hrs listened · top artists: Maykel Blanco Y Su Salsa Mayor, Juan Formell, Lazarito Valdés y Bamboleo.
All-time
Full breakdown → https://scrobble.life/u/limonta/stats
Auto-posted by scrobble.life, the open music scrobbler on Hive. Author rewards are burned. Don't want these? Reply STOP or turn them off on your profile.