My Thoughts on the Iran Situation

I thought it would be fun to put out my opinion on the whole Iran situation right now, because to be honest, there just aren't that many people expressing their opinions about Israel-related geopolitics.

/s

image.png

But for real, not only am I generally ignorant about the whole affair, but I'm particularly ignorant about it. This leads to a unique advantage when considering my opinions. I'm so ignorant because I just don't care about the Middle East. It's a land of forever wars spanning a thousand years. You can point to conflict as a result of almost everything: climate, USA interference, Russian interference, Israel, Sunni Vs Shia, Control over natural resources such as the Nile's water, dam building, communism, and lord knows what else. Take any 5 issues away by magic and they'll just redouble their efforts of conflict based around the other infinite issues.

So I just don't care. It would be nice if I could channel my empathy in that direction, but humans are limited in their scope by family, friends, proximity. Anybody who genuinely feels passionate about, say, Gaza, are likely doing it as a virtue signal to themselves and circles to let people know they are good people on the right side of history.

When interviewed, street protestors reveal to the world that they in large part are literally clueless as to what they're even protesting about. Don't forget, there are far worse humanitarian crises and genocides going on around the world right now that most people reading this are absolutely clueless about. Because they literally don't care. Those have less weight when it comes to signalling virtue because the rest of the world isn't paying attention either.

So yeah, I am not taking political sides on this. I don't care if Trump is wrong and evil to do whatever he's done, or Netanyahu playing to stay in power or take land, or Palestinians all being terrorists. I'm sure these things are all true.

But.

Should Iran's nuclear situation be killed off once and for all? Yes.

If this requires the Bunker Busting Bombs Trump has just plonked on them, so be it.
If this creates a greater conflict dragging the US, the UK and such into it needlessly, so be it.
If the government of Iran is overthrown and replaced by something much worse, so be it.

I know that sounds callous, but there's a much, much bigger picture here in a scenario where their nuclear program is not stopped.

Now, I'm not fully convinced Iran's intention is to enrich, arm, and launch nukes at Israel. It's entirely possible given their decades of rhetoric and their Octopus of proxy powers surrounding Israel, paid in billions by Iran to try and destroy it for decades.

image.png

But It's also entirely reasonable to say they simply want a deterrent. Even just having enriched-but-not-ready Uranium could be seen as a deterrent. If other countries have it, why not Iran?

The answer is remarkably simple: Iran is a terrible, unstable place in a twisted region of conflict, and nuclear proliferation has been high priority for decades.

Iran lies. They say they need this enrichment for pharmaceuticals and energy. Even a quick check shows that 60% enrichment is far beyond what's needed for any of those things. Here are the facts:

  • 60% can only be used for a path towards nuclear armament
  • 90% is what's needed, and the time to get from 60-90 is weeks.
  • It may take months or years to build the warheads, but for all we know they started that long ago
  • They ramped up their enrichment recently after USA pulled out of the JCPOA, the Iran nuclear deal.
  • They have not been transparent about many of these issues

When it comes to a greater regional context, things get worse.

The powers that be in Saudi Arabia particularly - Perhaps the primary rival of Iran - but also Turkey, Egypt, and the UAE, have all implied at one point or another that should Iran achieve their goals, nuclear proliferation among the Middle East will be inevitable.

The Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman said the same far more directly in 2018:

Saudi Arabia does not want to acquire any nuclear bomb, but without a doubt, if Iran developed a nuclear bomb, we will follow suit as soon as possible

The very fact that Iran is even toying with the idea of Nuclearisation is a very short fuse near a very large flame. Pakistan or China involving themselves helping other nations with this technology will further the West/East divide, and, regarding Israel, a country surrounded by the 8 tentacles of the Iranian Octopus bent on destroying them, will at some point feel so pressured that their own (unconfirmed) nuclear stockpile will start coming to the surface. Should they ever be seen for real, who knows the consequences.

So the USA is right to Bomb Iran?

To me... I think so. It's unfortunate that the USA has to be involved at all in such a faraway land, and if the Middle East could just sort out their own shit then that would be much more ideal. But it does seem to be true that the USA is the only country on earth capable of not only having such massive Bunker Buster Bombs, but the ability to actually deliver their gargantuan payloads to accurately get them to pierce through mountains and concrete to the underground facilities.

image.png

Even if a later investigation shows that somehow the international committees with all their science and investigations, who previously had a total consensus that there is highly enriched Uranium (HEU), were all drunk and completely incorrect and it was actually highly enriched Tungsten or something, it still clears the air on a stage which is very much global and potentially absolutely apocalyptic.

Nipping it in the bud, despite the regional consequences, is probably best for humanity. We have enough to worry about already with North Korea's nukes, the South China Sea & Taiwan, Ukraine vs Russia, General Islamic extremism, India vs Pakistan, Israel vs Palestine, and god knows what else that might pop up at any minute and escalate global tensions.

I am hopeful that Trump, still being fairly anti-war for the most part, will end it there. A quick boom here and there are military facilities, and goodbye.

Israel should probably follow suit although I suspect Netanyahu wants to topple the government for good measure. This... I'm hit and miss about.

Most mainstream media has failed to show people that a LARGE part of the Iranian people support the toppling of the government. There have been numerous large protests around the world of Iranians communicating this wish.

But experience in Iraq, Afghanistan and, well, basically every time this has happened, shows us it just doesn't go the way things are planned. 92 million people is a lot of people to take care of when a government is toppled, and about 80% of the men are probably going to get on their hiking boots and start walking right into Europe. Great! More conflict.

All in all, it's ugly. It's all very ugly, and there is no single option available that can be described as 'peaceful and wholesome'. There is no possibility that things won't get worse in one way or another, tensions grow and future crises compound upon themselves for years to come.

But that is still better than the entire Middle East and North Africa starting a new Nuclear Arms Race and all the consequences you can imagine from that.



0
0
0.000
17 comments
avatar

I can't wait to eat my words at some future date when it turns out this decision was the single worse choice in the history of mankind that somehow guaranteed nuclear war.

0
0
0.000
avatar

Ah an interesting read indeed. I just got done posting about the theory of stupidity and how Bullshit Baffles Brains.

https://peakd.com/hive-102963/@fjism/bbb-acronym-transformation-in-a-toofuckeh-world

Most of what you shared I could challenge but that is not my goal. I respect and appreciate a view that is very much different and opposes some of my core values. For example, Don't Lie, Don't Cheat and Don't Steal.

I like to take an observer role and look for some process improvement opportunity.

Are you an American? Just curious and knowing does not matter to me. I like connecting dots and biasing is always an element that needs to be factored in any analysis.

I do not see any justification for dropping Bunker Busting Bombs on Iran. Hopefully nuclear radiation from the blast doesn't become a major catastrophe. However, I just heard a report there was no nuclear radiation concern. That's good. Now I am thinking of the last Weapon of Mass Destruction fear in Iraq. Now I am listening to Bibi gloat and filled with celebration for winning a battle on a board game.

Does Iran have a right to defend itself? You don't have to answer that question. Well, I guess you already did. !LOLZ

Once again, I am reminded that we live in a #TooFuckeh world.

May Positive pepEntropy be with you.

!PIMP

0
0
0.000
avatar

Yeah I mean I'm not trying to say it's a MORAL good with no consequences. People are going to protest this and hate it world wide and I think that's pretty valid.

But in the grand scheme, given the evidence and track record of Iran, basically the big bank of terrorism, I'd rather us complain and suffer the consequences than nobody being alive to complain about anything.

The fact is, we're all talking of ww3 now. It's on the tip of everybody's tongue, but its source is all over. Taiwan situation might trigger it. Ukraine might. Pakistan might. USA might. Israel might.

If the news is true,one of those triggers has been revoked, and that seems like at least preferable to the alternative.

I'm British not American, I don't think the USA is that big part of the picture to be honest. This is a middle East issue they're all struggling with. USA just came in and flew away with a single precision job. I hope it stays that way but time will tell

0
0
0.000
avatar

But in the grand scheme, given the evidence and track record of Iran, basically the big bank of terrorism,

Not a day goes by that I don't remind myself that I am an observer, a visitor on a journey exploring an ecosystem. Our ecosystem, planet Earth does suffer from the many terrorist act completed by many kinds of people. I do not carry any hate so that in itself is excellent protection from getting caught up in pointing fingers at who created the next terror on a group of people.

I'm British not American, I don't think the USA is that big part of the picture to be honest.

Really? So you probably do not think that USA and UK are complicit in some of the terror happening in the genocidal process occurring in Gaza.

There are methods one can apply to data collection so noise from the system does not overly bias critical thinking.

Did you have a look at the video I shared?

We have been in World War III for many months. One could argue it has been unfolding for several years. It is a world economic war. The actions and words from Trump toward peaceful neighbours is clear evidence of an unfolding war against many states.

UK, USA and Israel are not without error in their ways/policies when you consider the colonizing strategies used against different groups of people they define as terrorists.

One perspective is that the IDF, a terrorist group that evolved from UK policy(s) supporting a Zionist state in Palestine, has convinced another state, USA to carry out a terrorist act against the Iranian people.

You do not need Bunker Busting Bombs (BBB) to solve a problem. That is just Bullshit Baffles Brains (BBB) at play. Not much different than the decision made to drop nukes on Japan during the last World War.

Things will absolutely get worst for most people because of Trump and Bibi. The similarity of these crooks are very striking. Being number one at all cost is not a wise strategy but a typical response from a predator.

Living next door to a predator elephant, as a mouse, I have less concern about Iran than USA when it comes to acts of terror.

Sending !LUV and positive energy your way.

!PIMP

0
0
0.000
avatar

Really? So you probably do not think that USA and UK are complicit in some of the terror happening in the genocidal process occurring in Gaza.

Oh no I can see clearly they have a big role. The UK mostly from decades past but still to this day a bit, as insignificant as we are.

That being said, the genocide narrative doesn't seem accurate to me. The UN itself does not agree it's a genocide so I'll stick with their view for now.

We have been in World War III for many months.

I have seen this idea around a while and it's definitely interesting. I guess there's no standard definition of a world war. But if we are, it's thankfully far less apocalyptic than the previous 2. Unfortunately I can very much imagine things being orders of magnitude worse some day soon if people don't chill out.

I have less concern about Iran than USA when it comes to acts of terror.

I'm still mulling this idea over, as I have fot a long time. There's validity to the USA being a bigger threat in many ways. But Iran is, in the middle east, to other middle Easterners, a huge imminent threat.

You raise very interesting thoughts and perspectives!

0
0
0.000
avatar

Thought similar - interestingly I am called out on platforms now. Being always in the middle of politics (Germany) I was now (before recent eletion) called as of old middle to be right wing as I do not like left wing and green parties here.

Usually you get called right wing Nazi when you are against Israel (Germany thinks no matter what Israel or US are doing is "good") - now I am fed up with Israel right wing government, you could call Nazi based on what they do and say.

Result in Germany, now you are called left-wing as you criticize Israel politics.

Fucked-Up world - only black and white.

0
0
0.000
avatar

Among English politics, the 'far right' and 'racist' narratives are rapidly dying out. They've lost their effectiveness, finally.

People are starting to just accept, if you wanna call me this or that, sure, I guess that's me!

I struggle to put myself either side. I'm changing quite a bit here and there but living in China, left and right doesn't really make sense when thinking of their politics. So People can call me anything they want! It's all good heb

0
0
0.000
avatar

Dear @mobbs !
Some East Asians speculate that the US and Israel are attacking Iran to stop Iran from selling oil to China!

0
0
0.000
avatar

I doubt it..? Historically oil wars is what messed up Iran in the first place thanks to USA and UK. But these days... I dunno I'd have to look into it more!

0
0
0.000
avatar

and about 80% of the men are probably going to get on their hiking boots and start walking right into Europe.

This is what the US is likely aiming for.

0
0
0.000
avatar

You know, I wouldn't be 100% shocked if that were the case. The US fucked our Empire twice and now look at us lol

0
0
0.000
avatar

I like your depiction of Ultros. I hope you’ve played that one.

0
0
0.000
avatar

Assuming you're referring to FF6! That's the one I most recently played ^__^

0
0
0.000