RE: Strait of Hormuz and the Iran War – Part 1: The Bogeyman of the Middle East
You are viewing a single comment's thread:
Thanks for your elaborate reply.
I relied on two surveys from the University of Maryland. Some of the survey results also include results from previous surveys. Surveys can definitely be biased in various different ways, e.g., sample selection and framing of questions. Even if that is the case, the results are unlikely to be completely wrong. That would involve a deliberate attempt to distort results over decades of surveys. I feel it is unlikely to be the case.
Some of the results indicate dissatisfaction with the Iranian Government. The people believe their economy is in a terrible state, and they put more blame on mismanagement and corruption than they do sanctions. They don't believe their government cares about how they feel. They feel women should not be confronted if they don't wear a hijab.
Outside of the survey there is evidence that people support their regime even if they are dissatisfied with many aspects of their Government.
There were huge turnouts for Khamenei's funeral. Al Jezeera claimed 12 million people in Tehran alone. That might be an exaggeration, but there is plenty of video footage from numerous sources showing vast numbers of people attending.
The voter turnout for the first and second rounds of voting in the presidential election was around 40% and 50%. Other elections, such as parliamentary and assembly of experts, are showing similar voter turnouts of 40%+. These numbers are low but similar to voter turnouts in recent UK elections. If support of the system were that dire, people would either not vote or the Iranian Government would force voting upon them.
There have been several occasions of unrest in Iran. One of the most significant being the unrest in 2022 over the death of a Kurdish woman who was arrested for not wearing a hijab. The unrest eventually ended. Since then, the Iranian government has loosened hijab enforcement. This aligns with the sentiments in the survey.
The Iranians have had 47 years to overthrow their leaders. It does not appear they have ever come that close. During the recent ceasefire, there has been no serious attempt to attack a weakened IRGC. The regular Iranian army has never attempted to attack the IRGC or rally the people to fight them.
I believe that Mossad has been able to infiltrate the Iranian Government because of the extent of corruption. I think this means that their loyalty can be bought.
Muslims in general stay loyal to their faith. That's why they have created so many problems in Europe because they want their Islamic culture to supersede existing European cultures. The Islamic Republic's constitution embodies the teachings of Islam and is consistent with their faith. The laws of the Islamic version of God over the laws of man. It is not compatible with democracy.
The Persian diaspora are people or descendants of people who fled Iran mostly in the 80s and 90s because of persecution. Most of them are not Muslim. Their family and the communities of their family who remain in Iran are likely to still face some form of persecution. However, they are only a small percentage of the overall population of Iran.
I don't think we can necessarily conclude that the majority of Iranians hate Israelis or Americans. The answers to one of the questions indicate that many Iranians want a peaceful coexistence with the West (not sure that includes Israel). Realistically, a peaceful coexistence does not look likely any time soon.
Interesting. A lot of conflicting data about the views of the Iranian people.
I've seen data suggesting that only 30% of Iranians are actually Shia Muslims and that there is a big move to atheism and Zorastriansim.
But ultimately the proof is in the pudding. If they don't overthrow their government after being given plenty of opportunity and support to do so they must be considered responsible for its actions and thus bear the consequences.
There has been a tendency in the West and Israel to say that X people are repressed by their government and are not responsible for its actions.
Israel has said it is at war with Hamas, not Gaza, with Hezbollah, not Lebanon, with the Iranian regime, not the Iranian people. The US has adopted a similar position.
I think this is fundamentally wrong with regard to Gaza, where Hamas and the Oct 7 atrocities had overwhelming support. Not a single Gazan helped a hostage escape and when they did escape the population handed them back to Hamas.
With Lebanon it appears that the distinction may be justified.
With Iran I think the distinction is looking less and less justified.
Ultimately the people in a country are responsible for the actions of their government, whether it is a democracy or not. They always have the power to change their government, even if that involves the use of force rather than just voting.
So unless there is clear evidence, like Lebanon where the government has formally agreed to Israeli occupation to remove Hizbollah, the country as a whole needs to be made to bear the price.
This means that complete destruction of Iranian infrastructure and use of tactical nuclear weapons to destroy Pikeaxe mountain needs to be on the agenda.
The West is being too soft and playing into victimhood narratives where people are not responsible for their actions or even inaction.
I think the 30% of Shia Muslim statistic more closely aligns with overseas Iranians. According to a survey, roughly 30% of American-Iranians identify as Muslim (PAAIA).
Mosque attendance in Iran is low. Some might argue that this is an indication that a considerably lower percentage of the population is actually Muslim. However, mosque attendance in Iran has been low for a long time. In 2006, less than 30% attended mosques weekly (Researchgate).
There are at least 6000 inactive mosques (Iranwire). Other sources are claiming as many as 50,000 are inactive/closed.
It looks like Iranians are moving towards more secular beliefs (Iran Academia Journals). It seems like a slow shift. I doubt there is enough urgency or anger to spark a revolution anytime soon. The next year or so will answer that question.