The Green Superpower – Diederik Samsom: Idealism and Realism

My respect for Diederik Samsom has grown once again after listening to his book The Green Superpower. I have been following Diederik for a couple of decades now. Not personally, of course, but ever since his early days after graduating in nuclear physics and becoming involved in Greenpeace with campaigns I certainly did not always agree with. I then followed his political career in the Netherlands and, eventually, his move to Europe, where he played a major role under Frans Timmermans in shaping the European Green Deal.

I have always respected him. And the more I read, hear and learn about him, the greater that respect became. Diederik is an idealist, but not someone who gets stuck in his own convictions. He tries to turn his beliefs into practical plans that can actually be implemented and ultimately benefit society as a whole. He has a green heart through and through, but understands that you cannot change the world simply by telling people what it should look like.

From idealism to realism

One of the things I particularly appreciate about Diederik is his willingness to reconsider his own views. He started out as a committed left-wing idealist, but over the years has come to understand that the changes we need cannot be achieved through idealism alone. Sometimes you have to move away from your original positions and accept that there are other interests at stake, beyond the convictions that got you started in the first place.

We can clearly see this in his career in Europe. As one of the driving forces behind the Green Deal, he was not only involved in developing ambitious plans for the green transition, but also experienced first-hand what it takes to get those plans through the European political machinery.

The book offers an interesting insight into the workings of the European Commission. I found it particularly useful to finally get a better understanding of what the Green Deal actually entails and how something of this scale comes together within the EU.

Samsom describes how the ambitious plans for the green transition in 2020 did not end up gathering dust when COVID struck. Quite the opposite. The economic recovery following the pandemic became an opportunity to make the green transition a central part of Europe's recovery strategy.

Ultimately, €750 billion was made available under the name NextGenerationEU. I also found the way this was achieved financially quite interesting. Joint European borrowing was politically sensitive, particularly for countries such as the Netherlands and Germany. Yet a way was found within the existing European framework to borrow money collectively. A typical example of how the EU sometimes manages to find a way around what initially appears politically impossible.

The book also highlights another European paradox. Countries such as the Netherlands and Germany want fewer European rules and a smaller European administration. At the same time, those very same countries want to make sure European funds are spent properly and that there is sufficient oversight. That inevitably requires rules, supervision and people to enforce them. Fewer rules mean greater trust, but trust between member states is not always in abundant supply. And so the European apparatus continues to grow.

screenshot - starting to love 'Storytel' app - with this one, finished book number 4

Energy is not a left-wing or right-wing issue

What particularly stayed with me is the way Samsom puts the energy transition into a much broader perspective. Sustainability is still sometimes presented as a left-wing cause. Something for environmentally conscious activists or, to put it less kindly, the sandal-wearing, woolly-socked brigade. But that perception is becoming increasingly outdated.

The energy transition is not just about climate change. It is every bit as much an economic and geopolitical issue. Europe has very limited fossil fuel resources of its own and depends on other countries for much of its energy supply. In a world where international relationships are shifting and energy is increasingly being used as a political weapon, that puts Europe in a particularly vulnerable position.

There is another reason why I believe the transition is unavoidable, and it goes beyond climate policy or Europe's geopolitical position. I have never really understood how we could possibly continue to rely on fossil fuels indefinitely. It takes millions of years for nature to produce these resources, yet we are burning through what took all that time to create in little more than a century. It is an extraordinary imbalance. We are consuming a finite resource at a pace that nature simply cannot replenish.

Why would we build our future around something that is bound to run out when we have access to energy sources that are effectively inexhaustible on a human timescale?

Wind, solar and hydropower offer Europe the opportunity to become far more self-sufficient. Add nuclear energy, hydrogen and large-scale energy storage to the mix, and we can create an entirely different energy landscape. One in which we are much less dependent on the whims of international energy markets and the countries that dominate them.

This also ties in with Mario Draghi's report on European competitiveness. The green transition is not simply a cost or an obligation imposed by climate policy. It can become a major economic driver. Cheaper energy, new industries and reduced dependence on imported energy are all directly relevant to Europe's future.

And that is an important point. Whatever your political preference, left or right, it is difficult to argue against a Europe that has greater control over its energy supply, keeps its industries competitive and is less exposed to geopolitical developments beyond its control.

Working with our neighbours

Another interesting aspect of the book is the idea that Europe should not organise its energy future entirely within its own borders. Cooperation with our southern and eastern neighbours offers enormous opportunities.

Samsom, for example, describes the potential of Mauritania, where sunlight and wind are available in abundance. This energy could be used to produce hydrogen, which in turn could serve as fuel for industrial processes and the production of intermediate goods. Ukraine also offers significant opportunities, with its natural resources, available land for renewable energy production and potential for offshore wind energy.

There are also cooperation projects with Morocco and plans for Egypt. The latter example particularly appeals to me: combining large-scale solar energy with hydropower and energy storage using a water reservoir, allowing Egypt not only to meet its own energy needs but potentially to supply some of that energy to Europe as well.

What I find important here is the way Samsom approaches this cooperation. It is not about creating another form of dependency in which Europe takes energy and resources from other countries without those countries benefiting themselves. The intention is for these investments to strengthen local economies and benefit local populations too. Europe gains access to energy and resources, while the countries involved benefit from investment, infrastructure, economic development driven by the energy this setup produces.

People need to come along too

There is another aspect of these major plans that can easily be overlooked: the people themselves. No matter how ambitious or economically attractive you make the energy transition sound, people ultimately have to be willing and able to live with it.

Samsom describes several projects in the Netherlands where existing homes were transformed into net-zero-energy homes. What stands out is that the most successful projects were not necessarily those with the best technical solutions. They were the ones where residents were personally involved from the very beginning. Builders who took the time to speak to residents, explain what was going to happen and address individual concerns achieved the best results.

That is hardly surprising. Major changes require public support. And for many people, sustainability remains an abstract concept until they are personally confronted with a substantial investment. Even among people who can comfortably afford it, the question often comes down to the same thing: how much am I actually paying for energy, and what will this investment save me?

That is a significant challenge. You can allocate hundreds of billions of euros at European level and come up with impressive plans, but if you fail to bring the population along, putting those plans into practice becomes a whole lot harder. That applies to renovating a home just as much as it does to the energy transition as a whole.

We could do with more people like Diederik Samsom

I consider Diederik Samsom an exceptionally intelligent and capable person. A fighter, too. That does not mean I have always agreed with his political choices or the way he has approached certain issues. But that does little to diminish my appreciation of him as a person and of his determination to actually make things happen.

What appeals to me most is that he has not abandoned his convictions, but has learned to combine them with realism. He understands that major changes sometimes require compromise, that economic interests matter and that you also have to convince people who do not necessarily share your way of thinking.

Perhaps, in some respects, he has even shifted somewhat to the right. Not because his environmental convictions have disappeared, but because he has come to understand that the green transition is much more than a left-wing political project. It is about our economy, our industry, our energy supply and, ultimately, Europe's independence.

I genuinely believe that renewable energy can eventually give us access to an abundance of energy at virtually no cost. Wind and solar are already cheaper than fossil fuels in many situations, and the cost of generating renewable energy has considerable scope to fall further. Once we add sufficient energy storage, at European and national level, but also at neighbourhood and household level, we can build an energy system that runs entirely on renewable sources while providing a reliable supply around the clock.

Just think about the possibilities. Energy that is available in abundance, at a fraction of today's cost, without having to dig it out of the ground, transport it across continents or depend on countries that control the supply. That is a fundamental change in the way we produce and consume energy. And it is a future worth working towards.

This is not some distant fantasy dreamed up by environmental activists. It is a development that increasingly makes economic and geopolitical sense and is happening under the radar already.

We could do with more people like Diederik Samsom. People who strongly believe in something but are equally prepared to question their own assumptions. People who do not simply stand on the sidelines shouting about how everything should be different, but are willing to take responsibility and actually make change happen.

The Green Superpower has only strengthened my respect for Samsom. What the book reinforces for me is not simply the importance of the green transition, but the sheer necessity of moving towards a fundamentally different energy future. We cannot keep consuming finite resources that take millions of years to form as if there were no tomorrow. Renewable energy offers us the opportunity to break away from that model altogether, potentially giving future generations access to virtually unlimited energy at almost no cost.

That is a prospect worth fighting for. And it takes people like Diederik Samsom, people willing to stick their necks out and turn that prospect into reality.

Five stars ***** on a scale from 0 to 5, 100% 🙏


an original



0
0
0.000
5 comments
avatar

Will have this in my reading list, I need to study a lot and read more on this issue!

Sustainability is still sometimes presented as a left-wing cause.

I never really understand this because many right-wing has interests in homesteading and self-sufficiency which actually is a part of living a sustainable life and supporting sustainability. But I do understand when viewed through political framework and the global institution that are involved, that is another story.

Also, I actually work in this exact sector now, and I find these kinds of visions both fascinating and frustrating. A lot of what is being discussed, and even implemented elsewhere, looks great. But over here in Indonesia, much of it still exists as pretty decks, ambitious policy documents, and polished presentations of what sustainability is supposed to look like.

From what I've seen in the trenches, the reality is far messier. The permitting process alone, man. You'd be surprised how much bureaucracy, political interference, and questionable human behavior can stand between a perfectly reasonable idea and its actual implementation 🤣

To be fair, the biggest obstacle to this transition isn't just the technology. It's governance and the people involved (at least 'round here).

0
0
0.000
avatar

It is not that much different in Europe.

Though Europe is always pushing for sustainability in energy and other sectors. Climate tops are driven by EU ambition. But the EU itself doesn't have much power over its member states. However, the EU introduced mechanisms in the past, like the CO2 certificates. A company that creates CO2, needs certificates to allow this, and obviously they have to buy it. Each year, less C02 certificates are released trending to zero new certificates in 2035, or close to that year. They also set a stop date to production of fossiel fuel engines in cars by 2035. Under pressure of the right wing political parties - gaining momentum in recent years/decade - this date is now pushed out to 2024, I believe. Fossil fuel companies lobbyists are also putting pressure to the greenification.

Fortunately in my country the midwing parties (left/right) setup huge government funds to support those individuals contributing to greenification. Such like no taxes on electrical cars. Support when putting solar cells on our houses. Support to those private companies building wind parks and solar cell parks. As a result, around 30% of our energy comes from sun and wind. Without such financial support, I do not think we would've been where we are. Anybody consuming energy in my country, benefits from this. In spring and summer we have days in which energy costs goes below zero, ie we earn money when using electricity instead of paying. We still lack big energy storage for later use. Batteries are becoming a big thing now. Still small in total capacity, but the first home owners are now investing into these aiming to make there homes more or less self sufficient in terms of electricity. Gas is the next thing to deal with. Most people cook with gas. We shall transform this to electricity. I do hope we'll succeed, but with far/ultra right wing political parties becoming bigger and bigger, their electorate mostly denying climate change, and not able to see the business case for renewable energy, I wonder how many years we'll need.

Cost before benefits is what makes greenification difficult.
Citizens embracing greenification is a darn hard thing. They all need to do something, change habits and all that which is darn difficult to drive since most people do not want to change their behaviour and habits.

I do hope you'll going to see changes in Indonesia in the next years to a decade. Hopefully driven by even cheaper setups for collecting and distributing renewable energy.

0
0
0.000
avatar

What stands out most about Diederik Samsom is his ability to balance environmental idealism with practical solutions that consider economic realities and public support.

I agree that transitioning to renewable energy is about more than protecting the environment; it is also about energy independence, economic stability, and reducing reliance on finite resources.

The real challenge is ensuring these advancements remain affordable and accessible so everyone can benefit from a more sustainable future.

0
0
0.000
avatar

Agree. Regarding the accesibility: In my country everybody can choose energy plans with 100% green energy. One doesnt have to invest anything in production, just switch to such plan. At some point in time everyone in the world will be offered similar access to green energy.

0
0
0.000