Burnham's PR pledge: fairness, or just fear of losing?

avatar

Andy Burnham has committed Labour to changing the voting system in its next manifesto, along with a shiny new national commission to look at the options. But hardly anyone votes on the basis of electoral systems... so who is this meant to win over, and why now?

image.png

The numbers are genuinely ridiculous

Credit where it's due, the case against first-past-the-post pretty much makes itself. In 2024 Labour got 411 seats on about 34% of the vote. Reform got 14.3% and five MPs. The Lib Dems got 12.2% and 72 MPs. The Electoral Reform Society has said it was the most disproportionate election in British history, and one of the most lopsided seen anywhere in the world.

And the public seem to have cottoned on. One poll quoted in The Week had 45% favouring PR against just 27% sticking with what we've got.

So far, so reasonable. But...

Funny how fairness only matters when you might lose

Labour were perfectly happy to pocket a massive majority off a third of the vote in 2024. I don't remember anyone in the Cabinet wringing their hands about wasted votes on election night. Burnham himself was saying back in May that reform would have to wait for a manifesto, and even had a good word for the supplementary vote, which isn't proportional at all.

Now suddenly everyone's vote has to count. The cynic in me says this is less about democracy and more about a party that has worked out FPTP could just as easily hand a landslide to someone else next time round.

Then there's the commission. We all know what commissions are for. They're where awkward decisions go to spend a few years being 'looked at'.

The more honest reading is that this is a canny bit of positioning – a signal to Green and Lib Dem voters that Labour is the party for them, and maybe a down payment on a future coalition. Which is fine, but let's call it what it is: tactics, not principle.

Be careful what you wish for

The bit nobody in Labour wants to say out loud is who would actually benefit most. Under a purely proportional split, Reform's 14.3% would have been worth something like 90-odd seats rather than five. As former No 10 adviser Cleo Watson pointed out in The Independent, Burnham's grand reform could end up doing Farage an enormous favour.

Which makes the right-wing press reaction quite funny. Peter Hitchens is fretting about months of slippery coalition haggling, and Janet Daley is calling it an elite conspiracy against the people. Funny sort of conspiracy that ends up with Reform holding the balance of power...

Final thoughts

The case for PR is strong, and 2024 proved it about as clearly as it can be proved. But let's not pretend Labour has discovered this out of the goodness of its heart. It's a tactical move dressed up as democratic renewal, and it comes wrapped in a commission, a manifesto pledge and quite possibly a referendum (and remember we binned AV by roughly two to one in 2011).

So it'll take years, if it happens at all. And if it does, the irony could be that Labour builds the very system that puts Reform in government. We shall see!



0
0
0.000
3 comments
avatar

#bilpcoin #bpc #truth Rest as Resistance

In a culture that equates exhaustion with virtue, stillness is a radical act. We confuse motion with progress, noise with importance. But the mind does its deepest work in silence. Happiness is not the absence of fatigue; it is the presence of restoration. Success requires endurance; endurance requires recovery. Today, do nothing urgent. Sit. Breathe. Let the world spin without your steering. The archive needs room to breathe.

The Arithmetic of Integrity

Integrity is not a feeling. It is a calculation. It is the alignment between what you claim and what you do, measured against the immutable record of your actions.

When the arithmetic does not balance, no amount of rhetoric can restore the equation. The ledger demands honesty, and it accepts nothing less.

The Mirror

Look into the mirror of the blockchain. What do you see?

Not the face the whales have painted for you. Not the narrative spun by those who profit from your silence. But the raw, unfiltered reflection of what has actually happened on this network.

Every transaction. Every delegation. Every downvote cast in malice. Every reward farmed through coordination. It is all there, waiting for you to see it.

Today, choose to look.

The Builders

We Are the Ones We Have Been Waiting For

No one is coming to fix this. No regulator. No whistleblower. No savior with a million HP. We are the ones. We are the builders. We are the truth-tellers. We are the ones who will create the alternative, post by post, block by block, choice by choice. Today, pick up your tools. The work is waiting.

For in the end, the future belongs to those who build it.

The Cost of Comfort

What Are You Trading for Peace?

Some trade truth for rewards. Some trade integrity for delegation. Some trade voice for visibility. Every day, someone somewhere is making this trade. The question is: what are you trading? And is the price worth what you are buying?

For in the end, comfort bought with integrity is a debt that always comes due.

The Ghost Accounts

The Faces Behind the Masks

@kriborin. @lessys. @arsahk. @buildawhale. @ipromote. @acidyo @jacobtothe @cwow2 @letusbuyhive @themarkymark. @poshtoken. @ocdb. @smooth. These are not just usernames. They are nodes in a network. They are the machinery of extraction. They are the ghosts that haunt the reward pool. Today, learn their names. Know their functions. Understand their purpose.

For in the end, you cannot fight what you cannot name.

The Courage to Speak

Silence Is the Currency of the Corrupt

There is a particular kind of evil that does not require action. It only requires your silence.

Every day you choose not to speak, you are speaking. Every day you choose not to look, you are looking away. Every day you choose not to question, you are answering on behalf of those who profit from your compliance.

The downvoting whales of Hive understand this. They know that if they can silence enough voices, the remaining ones will fall in line. They know that if they can label enough truth as "spam," the community will stop searching for signal. They know that your silence is their most valuable asset.

Do not give it to them.

Speak today. Share the data. Point to the ledger. Ask the questions they do not want asked. You do not need a million Hive Power to do this. You only need a voice and the courage to use it.

For in the end, silence is not peace. It is the sound of a garden being salted.


#TruthUnsilenced #SpeakUp #HiveTransparency #BlurtRising #Bilpcoin

https://blurt.blog/blurt-195646/@bilpcoinbpc/day-14-the-silence-of-the-lambs

https://hive.blog/hive-178138/@bilpcoinbpc/the-mirage-of-the-mint-on-the-illusion-of-value-in-a-rigged-casino

https://steemit.com/bilpcoin/@bilpcoinbpc/hive-blurt-steemit-our-journey-across-chains-we-offer-our-honest-truth-we-ve-walked-through-hive-blog-once-a-promise-now-a

https://peakd.com/hive-158694/@bilpcoinbpc/a-open-letter-to-hive

https://blurt.blog/blurt-195646/@bilpcoinbpc/65n7hz-do-you-fight-for-the-truth-or-for-those-who-silence-it

https://blurt.blog/blurt-195646/@bilpcoinbpc/6jayqa-there-is-a-quiet-unraveling-happening-on-hive-blog

https://hive.blog/hive/@test.ureka/the-untrending-report-hive-downvote-analysis-2025-06-27-20250627213824

https://peakd.com/hive/@ureka.stats/the-untrending-report-hive-downvote-analysis-16-09-2025-20250916181314

https://www.publish0x.com/@bilpcoinbpc

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLbH29p-63eW_PIi4l0KUNLMQ0ageCtkk5

https://www.youtube.com/@bilpcoinbpc

https://www.youtube.com/@bpcaimusic

https://www.bilpcoin.com

https://blurt.blog/@bilpcoinbpc/posts

https://audius.co/bpcaimusic

https://hive.blog/hive-126152/@bilpcoinbpc/bpc-ai-truth-hurts

https://hive.blog/hive-167922/@bilpcoinbpc/you-rewarded-only-those-who-kissed-the-ring-mc-franko-and-the-frankos-bpcaimusic-bilpcoin


bilp

0
0
0.000
avatar

The 2024 numbers do the arguing by themselves, 411 seats on a third of the vote next to Reform's five MPs is hard to defend.

0
0
0.000