RE: Scary Times: Turns Out Hope Wasn't Enough
You are viewing a single comment's thread:
This sure is a sad and scary development. But it's worth considering the reasons behind it. If people feel that their only alternative is "the Alternative" it also means the failure of everyone else: the mainstream and the actual alternatives (provided they do exist).
Which political parties represent the interests of Big Business, corporations and investors, rather than the average individual employee?
The FDP? - Most certainly.
The CDU? - Also apparently.
The SPD? - Them too, allegedly.
The Greens? - Not sure, quite honestly. (Though I wouldn't put it past them.)
The BSW / Linke / PDS / SED or any of its incarnations? - Doesn't matter, really.
If anything, I see the extreme left very similarly to the AfD, meaning that they're merely a fringe option, to indicate voters' disillusion with the rest. Kinda like the APPD used to be: not meant to win and govern, but instead ring the alarm bells so the mainstream would get its act together. And it's still not too late for that.
But now that the AfD has actually achieved these results, it's worth pointing out: They also represent money (and those who have lots of it but want more still)! As you mentioned, their tax plans reveal their intentions. But doesn't Alice Weidel also have close ties to Goldman Sachs? Yeah, so much for the "alternative" then. So maybe those teens got it right, and the best option is the Linke, or even better, whichever alternative ideas are lumped together under "others".
That's a really good point, and honestly a fair one. If the "alternative" is the only place people feel heard, the failure isn't only on their side. It's everyone else's - mainstream and actual alternatives included.
And you're right about Weidel. She worked as an analyst at Goldman Sachs. So yeah. "Anti-establishment" from someone who came straight out of the establishment's finance wing. That's not an accident either. That's who they actually serve, and it's not the people voting for them out of frustration.
On your list of parties: The Greens are representing big business too, meanwhile.
The APPD comparison is interesting too. A protest vote, meant to shake the mainstream awake, not meant to actually govern. Maybe that theory made sense once. But Sachsen-Anhalt just proved the AfD isn't staying a protest anymore. 43.8% isn't a wake-up call. It's a government. At some point "protest vote" stops being a good explanation for what's happening.
And yes - maybe the U18 result really was the more honest read of where things could go. Not proof of anything yet but maybe it's proof that when people actually look for who represents them instead of just who's loudest against everyone else, they land somewhere very different. Fingers crossed for future generations..
Well, now that it's time to govern, we can finally see them in action. (Though I'm a bit doubtful, since they don't have 2/3 majority and no other party wants a coalition with them...) But if they manage to get a gov't going, they can finally prove to their constituents whether they're worth their salt. And since it's only on the state level, it's still relatively safe. They won't be changing the constitution, or anything, and they will still be bound by federal law. But what kind of government will they offer? Like Orban's FIDESZ in Hungary? Or like Trumps Republicans in the US? Granted, neither option is all too desirable, but if nothing else, they serve(d) as further wake-up calls. This time not for the mainstream, but their own followers.
Yeah they are limited in what they can do and their program is a wishlist for EU-law things they will never be able to pull off under state law but alone their intentions are scary:
They want to reorient schools around performance and national identity. They want to confiscate cash and valuables like jewelry from refugees entering the country, and to mandate invasive medical age tests. Most of the cultural funding in the state is under their influence and they wanna set up some "citizen watch squad" running around next to actual police (Gestapo-vibes) and much more.
You frame it as "Give them a fair chance to govern and proof what they can" which is the most dangerous take you can make. The NSDAP started like what they are doing right now.
You are right, I have had the same attitude about the Republicans: all these amazing ideas, but they never could implement any of them, they cried, because of the Democrats. Okay then, this time they have it all: the executive branch, both houses in Congress, plus a judiciary leaning in their favor. So what about all those great plans? Never mind, instead they are running the country off a cliff. Sure, it will most likely finish them off, but at what cost?
The other thing I have been in favor of, as a general idea, is to give each way of thinking its own space, provided people are in favor of it. You want Sharia law? Sure, you can organize yourself and implement it in your town for yourself and your supporters. Those who agree with you will follow. Those who don't like it will leave. You want communal ownership? Go right ahead, and practice it with your fellow communists. As long as free movement is guaranteed, and no one tries to impose their ideas on others, this should work... in theory. But again, in practice it may not be this simple.
you should look up what the AfD writes in their program. They have a lot of good ideas to get Germany back on track.